Race to the Finish: The 2000 and 1968 Total Return Bears
October 19, 2010

Note from dshort: In response to a request from Eric in Nashville, I've added a pair of total return charts to this series.


Here's a total return version of chart duo I posted earlier today.

The first chart is an overlay of total returns (dividends reinvested) for the two periods. Since stocks paid much higher dividends during the earlier period, the performance of the 1968-1982 is dramatically superior to the returns we've seen since the market peak in 2000.

Click to View
Click for a larger image

After we adjust both for inflation (using the BLS Consumer Price Index) the apparent dividend advantage of the earlier period gradually evaporates.

Click to View
Click for a larger image

Of course, the timeframes illustrated in these charts are radically different from one another in many ways — inflation rates, dividend yields, federal debt, average GDP, among them. When future historian compare these two periods, they will probably point to the demographic shift from young Boomers in the early phases of their careers to aging Boomers on the threshold of retirement with a growing sense of their financial vulnerability.


Use the links at the top of this four-chart series to study the comparisons in more detail.