Bear Markets and the S&P 500
By Doug Short
November 12, 2007

A bear market is commonly defined as a decline of 20% in a major index from a recent peak over a 12 month period. Since 1950 there have been eight declines greater than 20% in the S&P 500. However, three of those declines, from previous high to bottom, were of shorter duration than 12 months and thus wouldn't fit this definition. For example, the crash of 1987 was part of a dramatic decline of 33.5% in the S&P 500. But it lasted only three months from peak to trough. Similarly the 20% plus declines that began in 1962 and 1966 lasted only 7 and 8 months, respectively.

The chart below annotates all eight 20% plus declines in the S&P 500 since 1950. The percent decline is shown in red and the percent gain from the previous low in blue. The data extends to the most recent high of 1565.15 on November 9, 2007.

Year

Date

Close

Range

Variance

Length in months

1950

3-Jan-50

16.66

Start

0.0%

-

1956

3-Aug-56

49.64

High

198.0%

80

1957

22-Oct-57

38.98

Low

-21.5%

15

1961

12-Dec-61

72.64

High

86.4%

50

1962

26-Jun-62

52.32

Low

-28.0%

7

1966

9-Feb-66

94.06

High

79.8%

44

1966

7-Oct-66

73.2

Low

-22.2%

8

1968

29-Nov-68

108.37

High

48.0%

26

1970

26-May-70

69.29

Low

-36.1%

18

1973

11-Jan-73

120.24

High

73.5%

32

1974

3-Oct-74

62.28

Low

-48.2%

21

1980

28-Nov-80

140.52

High

125.6%

75

1982

12-Aug-82

102.42

Low

-27.1%

21

1987

25-Aug-87

336.77

High

228.8%

61

1987

4-Dec-87

223.92

Low

-33.5%

3

2000

24-Mar-00

1,527.46

High

582.1%

150

2002

9-Oct-02

776.76

Low

-49.1%

31

2007

9-Oct-07

1,565.15

High

101.5%

61

Of the eight declines greater than 20%, the average was 33.2%. The length of time from peak to trough ranged from 3 to 31 months, with the average being 15 months.

The bull market phases were much longer, ranging from 26 to 150 months, with the average being 64 months.

The data presented here is not meant to suggest the beginning of a new bear market. However, the recent turmoil in the credit markets, the decline in the dollar, and signs of a slowdown in consumer spending suggest the possibility of a correction might be underway.

Whether we're in a momentary slump or the beginning of a longer downturn has been the subject of much controversy. Optimists discount the possibility of a recession and predict a "soft landing" for the United States economy.

Pessimists look back at the prolonged sideways market from 1968 to 1882 for a clue of what lies in store. That 14 year period, during which the S&P 500 bounced around the 100 point level, was characterized by stagflation -- a stagnant economy plagued by high inflation sometimes exceeding 10%. Thus far, inflation has remained under control. But the decline in the dollar and rising cost of oil and other commodities may lead to inflationary pressures.